Are you in a caring profession? I had the opportunity last week to visit the Midlands hub of a rather different one, no less caring, but where the object of their care is a parcel.
You’d think it was a different world to general practice and on the surface that appears to be the case, but the parallels are striking and fascinating. They call it a hub not as the latest management fad to soak up taxpayers’ money but because the hub is essential to the design and operation of the system. (All competing parcels businesses have a Midlands hub by the way).
It means that a parcel can be collected from your door anywhere in the UK and delivered to another door anywhere in the UK within 24 hours, and to do that for 5kg in any shape or size, for under £10, is simply astonishing.
At the system’s centre is the hub where lorries from 40 depots arrive throughout the evening and depart into the night. An arriving parcel can go out to any destination, and if it’s one of the 70% to go on the automated system it will spend just 7 minutes in the building. Most of the 300 workers however handle the odd shapes, sizes and special requirements of the 35,000 per night which can’t be automated. They are glad of £12-£14/hour for the 8pm – 3am shift, many of them immigrants and a third on agency books. It was hot on Monday night, and only the control room has a/c, but the work ethic, and it is hard work, is phenomenal.
So what about the parallels? You’d think a parcel is a parcel, but the “undifferentiated demand” they see ranges from a 150g padded envelope to a 1.5 tonne truck engine, a factor of 10,000 times by weight. They all get the same service. Is it urgent? Some are marked as such but there is no way of knowing the unique story behind each item. In truth it makes little difference, as there is no point hanging onto parcels overnight – they would just get in the way of tomorrow’s work.
What about the ethos? They sort everything tonight, barring a handful of especially fragile or flammable patients, I mean parcels, kept in for special treatment. They walk the lines to ensure nothing was missed and only then declare “End of sort”. Only then do they go home, and if it’s after 3am, they stay until done – last night was 3.39.
There’s the variety, and there’s the flow. Like general practice, parcels are not scheduled, they just turn up when they feel like it. But the volumes are predictable within quite a narrow range, and the pattern is tidal. Every evening lorries come in around the same time, every night they go out again full (except for the exceptions, breakdowns, accidents and so on, managed by humans).
“Tidal” seems to me the best description for general practice demand, predictable by day and by week, and I sense the next blog forming around a theme – the tidal deniers, tidal self harmers and tidal surfers.
Help me with a name, “How to be a GP surfer dude” or something.
askmyGP & GP Access Ltd
PS Thank you to Dr Kerri Monk, GP at Audley Mills, for her addition to last week’s blog. “I feel as a group of drs we’re finally working as a team. It’s great. I’m looking forward to week 2 already.”
PPS Fascinating interview on automating healthcare with Dr Jonathan Tomlinson, aka @mellojonny, in the Technoskeptic. “We got this fantastic robot that does the work of two men, but unfortunately it takes three to work it.’ The WebGP/eConsult thing is like that.”
We agree. And that’s why we have a totally different philosophy from webGP/eConsult, who are trying to divert patients from seeing a GP, or diagnose themselves and then get asked so many questions they lose the will to live. It doesn’t work. Computers are rubbish at this. Computers are very good at taking down what people say and speeding up communication. Which is how they save time for GPs. Which is why one of our GPs using askmyGP said to me last week she could manage a patient demand in two minutes which previously would have taken five minutes. Aha.
So now they are trying to increase the proportion of patient demands coming through askmyGP up from the current 20%. The clue on how comes from the main theme of patient feedback: “Easy to use and quick service.” Aha. “Quick service” is down to the practice, “Easy to use” is down to us and you’d be amazed how hard it is to make something easy! Our never finished project.