The “Flaw of Averages” was I understand first observed when a trainee statistician drowned while fording a river which he calculated had an average depth of 2 feet.
You can tell he was American. A British trainee would have made the average depth 0.945m.
We are seeing 7,000 online consultations per week through askmyGP, from about 250,000 patients covered. At 2.8% of total list, that would be about a third of total demand on average, right?
You know I’m going to say “wrong” and the flaw explains very simply why.
It turns out the practices divide into three cohorts, which I’ll call the swimmers, runners and rollers.
The swimmers see under 5% of demand online. There may be a lot of splashing, but speed over the ground is quite low, benefits are hard to measure and an adverse current may even sweep them away. An askmyGP icon decorates their website, leaflets and posters are all over reception but for any patient using it, service is slow and frankly, the telephone seems a safer bet.
Runners are in the range 20 – 40% online, it’s a main mode of access with good service and generally high patient satisfaction. Benefits for the practice are significant and they can handle all patient demand on the day. But they are still running two systems, with mixed messages to patients. While they know online is more efficient, they may still limit access, so patients revert to telephone.
Rollers are putting 100% of demand through askmyGP, between 50 and 80% online from patients, the rest by telephone into reception. In this total flow mode, GP digital triage means they manage all their workflow with an efficiency simply impossible by any other means.
What does this mean for us?
We want to increase usage because, while we incur some volume related costs, it’s much more valuable to us when customers and patients get the most benefit from askmyGP, and that is after all our vision.
But while it might be tempting to persuade, cajole or incentivise practices to push up their average % usage by a few points, it would be a waste of everyone’s time.
Quite simply, we need to get them all rolling along in total flow mode. They’ll experience the benefits all for themselves with no pushing and shoving from us.
Here’s the thing: all our customers have exactly the same software, and the same advice. They are just making different choices, and seeing radically different outcomes as a result.
The great news is that all our new launches are rolling from day one. It works best that way.
Any triathletes will have spotted the analogy but there’s an added twist: transition between the modes seems to be remarkably difficult. People settle into a mode of operation and to shift seems just, well, a bit of an effort.
It’s not impossible, with Witley & Milford shifting three weeks ago and immediately doubling their speed of flow. After one week, someone briefly went back to the old system and was very quickly corrected!
So while new practices are all getting the max, how do we move the others?
Scratches head.
Harry Longman
PS What about the spectators? Very simply and with no commitment, you can be the GP managing the incoming total demand. It’s real, randomised and anonymised patient data, and when you have your login it will take about 15 minutes to rattle through 50.
The Flaw of Averages
The “Flaw of Averages” was I understand first observed when a trainee statistician drowned while fording a river which he calculated had an average depth of 2 feet.
You can tell he was American. A British trainee would have made the average depth 0.945m.
We are seeing 7,000 online consultations per week through askmyGP, from about 250,000 patients covered. At 2.8% of total list, that would be about a third of total demand on average, right?
You know I’m going to say “wrong” and the flaw explains very simply why.
It turns out the practices divide into three cohorts, which I’ll call the swimmers, runners and rollers.
The swimmers see under 5% of demand online. There may be a lot of splashing, but speed over the ground is quite low, benefits are hard to measure and an adverse current may even sweep them away. An askmyGP icon decorates their website, leaflets and posters are all over reception but for any patient using it, service is slow and frankly, the telephone seems a safer bet.
Runners are in the range 20 – 40% online, it’s a main mode of access with good service and generally high patient satisfaction. Benefits for the practice are significant and they can handle all patient demand on the day. But they are still running two systems, with mixed messages to patients. While they know online is more efficient, they may still limit access, so patients revert to telephone.
Rollers are putting 100% of demand through askmyGP, between 50 and 80% online from patients, the rest by telephone into reception. In this total flow mode, GP digital triage means they manage all their workflow with an efficiency simply impossible by any other means.
What does this mean for us?
We want to increase usage because, while we incur some volume related costs, it’s much more valuable to us when customers and patients get the most benefit from askmyGP, and that is after all our vision.
But while it might be tempting to persuade, cajole or incentivise practices to push up their average % usage by a few points, it would be a waste of everyone’s time.
Quite simply, we need to get them all rolling along in total flow mode. They’ll experience the benefits all for themselves with no pushing and shoving from us.
Here’s the thing: all our customers have exactly the same software, and the same advice. They are just making different choices, and seeing radically different outcomes as a result.
The great news is that all our new launches are rolling from day one. It works best that way.
Any triathletes will have spotted the analogy but there’s an added twist: transition between the modes seems to be remarkably difficult. People settle into a mode of operation and to shift seems just, well, a bit of an effort.
It’s not impossible, with Witley & Milford shifting three weeks ago and immediately doubling their speed of flow. After one week, someone briefly went back to the old system and was very quickly corrected!
So while new practices are all getting the max, how do we move the others?
Scratches head.
Harry Longman
PS What about the spectators? Very simply and with no commitment, you can be the GP managing the incoming total demand. It’s real, randomised and anonymised patient data, and when you have your login it will take about 15 minutes to rattle through 50.
Register for our free Digital Triage Experience.
What you can read next
GP pay, rations and recruitment
Surfing the demand wave
So what is an e-consultation?