Perhaps surprisingly, latest figures from askmyGP showing patient contact activity are consistent with those from the equivalent period in 2019. Data show similar volumes of demand by patients, at approximately 6% of the practice list size making a request per week.

When offered a choice of ways to talk to their GP, 12% of patients expressed a preference for a face-to-face appointment, 34% preferred to be contacted by secure message and 50% by phone. Despite the obvious changes in methods of communication clinicians have continue to deliver care to their patients at a similar rate despite the effects of Covid.

Comparisons between years

Overall volumes of activity, expressed as percentage of the practice list making a request of their GP practice, are very similar when the same week is compared between 2020 and 2019.  For example, the effects of the Christmas and Easter breaks can be observed in both years (Easter was slightly earlier in 2020), alongside e.g. public holidays in early and late May.  Activity throughout the summer is nearly identical between years.

Communication methods

While similar proportions of cases were resolved, the mechanisms used to do so have changed substantially between years.  Compared to 2019, responses to patients made less use of face-to-face and more use of secure messages and telephone consultation – the effects of Covid precautions being the most obvious explanation.  Visits dropped from 0.92% to 0.53% and video usage remained low at 0.33% (not shown).

The askmyGP data is drawn from practices with diverse patient populations receiving a total of 4,067,068 patient requests during the year to date. The data illustrates patient contact by clinical episode, with video consultation and secure messaging with the patient’s usual NHS GP offered at no extra cost to either the practice or the patient.

Clinical judgement always takes precedence, meaning in some cases simple queries might be addressed by a quick answer by phone or message, while more complex presentations will warrant a face-to-face appointment, even in cases where this has not been requested by the patient. Practices are not bound by their patients’ contact preferences, but they use the information to guide their responses to patients.

Recent analysis by The Health Foundation similarly found that consultation rates changed only slightly – at askmyGP practices activity decreased by less than 1% between 1 March–30 June 2020, compared to the same period in 2019. However, they found there has been a dramatic swing away from face-to-face consultations. Between 1 March–30 June 2020, 8.5% of appointments were held face-to-face, compared to 38% during the same period in 2019. Use of remote consultation methods increased. Telephone appointments increased from 39% to 51%, online message from 23% to 40% and although video increased 50-fold, it remained low at 0.5%.

3 November 2020

Five million patient milestone reached by online consultation and workflow system askmyGP

Five million patient requests have been managed by GP practices using the askmyGP online consultation and workflow system since September 2018. The system is used by practices throughout the UK with a combined list size of over 2 million patients. Clinicians at the practices use the system’s online triage tools to prioritise and deliver care by secure message, telephone, video or face-to-face appointment.

In those requests, 70% of patients chose to contact their GP online via the practice website, while the remaining patients phoned their practice. Half of patient requests were completed by the practice in two hours or less, including requests made online outside normal surgery hours.

Overall, patients asked for face-to-face appointments in only 12% of cases. 50% of patients asked to be contacted by the practice by phone and 34% asked for a secure message from their clinician.  This pattern has varied considerably due to lockdown, with a clear shift away from face-to-face activities.

Across those patient requests, clinicians decided to see 12% of patients face-to-face. 86% of patients’ requests were resolved on the same day they contacted the practice.  Recent patterns differ somewhat and can be explored in the live data presented on our website.

Across the five million patient requests, between 5% and 7.5% of patients on the practice list made contact each week; we observed that seasonal fluctuation is greater than the changes observed during lockdown.  Patterns of demand in 2020 have remained similar to 2019 – this point is discussed further in our blog: patient preferences and clinicians’ choices in 2020

The five millionth patient request was received by the St John’s Medical Centre in Altrincham, early one Thursday in October 2020.  St John’s has been using askmyGP to manage all of its patient requests since January this year. The request was closed by telephone 51 minutes later.  GP partner Dr Marik Sangha said:

“With askmyGP we are simply getting through the work more efficiently.  Although we are supporting the same numbers of patients, most don’t need to come into the surgery – you don’t need to physically see them.  Nearly 80% of our patients make their request online, freeing up phone capacity for our more vulnerable patients who need more help.  Patient feedback has been extremely positive.”

Harry Longman, chief executive of Salvie Ltd, the company behind askmyGP, said:

“This is a major milestone, and we are delighted that askmyGP continues to enable patients to get help promptly from their own GP. Despite the challenges presented by the Covid pandemic practices are able to understand, predict and manage patient demand much more flexibly, putting them in control of who they see and when, and ensuring patients receive appropriate support despite challenging circumstances.”

3 November 2020

The 2019 full year figures from askmyGP reporting patient contact preferences show that when offered a choice of ways to engage with their GP Practice, 25% of patients expressed a preference for a face-to-face appointment, 26% asked to be contacted by secure message and 40% by phone.  Data show continued low demand among both patients and clinicians for video consultations (0.08%).

Clinical judgement always takes precedence, meaning in some cases simple queries might be addressed by a quick answer by phone or message, while more complex presentations will warrant a face-to-face appointment, even in cases where this has not been requested by the patient.  Practices are not bound by their patients’ contact preferences, but they use the information to guide their responses to patients.

The flow diagram illustrates the transitions between these ‘requested’ and ‘actual’ methods of delivery, indicating that the greatest shift was for patients who had asked for a phone call, but clinicians decided that a face-to-face appointment was needed.  The result of these transitions was that clinicians resolved 30% of enquiries face-to-face, 20% via message and 28% by phone.  In each case, clinicians were able to make use of the clinical presentation and medical history when selecting how best to address the patient’s needs.

The askmyGP data is drawn from practices with diverse patient populations receiving a total of 1.2 million patient requests during the period. The data illustrates patient contact by clinical episode, with video consultation with the patient’s usual NHS GP offered at no extra cost to either the practice or the patient. Unknown refers to cases where the preference was not recorded, even though help was provided to the patient.

25 February 2020

One million patient milestone reached by online consultation and workflow system askmyGP

One million patient requests have been managed by GP practices using the askmyGP online consultation and workflow system since September 2018. The system is used by practices across the UK with a combined list size of 545,485. Clinicians at the practices use the system’s online triage tools to prioritise and deliver care by secure message, telephone, video or face-to-face appointment.

64% of patients chose to contact their GP online via the practice website, while the remaining patients phoned their practice. Half of patient requests were completed by the practice in two hours or less, including requests made online outside normal surgery hours.

Patients asked for face-to-face appointments in only 25% of cases. 45% of patients asked to be contacted by the practice by phone and 30% asked for a secure message from their clinician.

On reviewing patient requests, clinicians decided to see 37% of patients face-to-face. 88% of patients who needed an appointment attended the practice on the day they contacted the practice.

Across the one million patient requests, 6.5% of patients on the practice list made contact each week.

The one millionth patient request was received by the Concord Medical Centre in Bristol, which has been using askmyGP to manage all of its patient requests for more than two years. Senior partner Dr Simon Bradley said: “With askmyGP we are getting through the work more efficiently and continuity of care has improved too, with more patients consulting with their preferred GP. There are days where all outstanding consultations have been completed by 5.30pm, allowing the duty GP to manage urgent problems and process late requests that otherwise would have been passed forward to the following day.”

Harry Longman, chief executive of GP Access Ltd, the company behind askmyGP, said: “This is a major milestone and we are delighted that askmyGP has enabled a million patients to get help sooner from their own GP. That’s only possible by making it easier for practices to understand, predict and manage patient demand much more flexibly, putting them in control of who they see and when, managing their resources appropriately for each patient.”

The latest figures from askmyGP reporting patient contact preferences are consistent with those from earlier in the year. Data show continued low demand among patients for video consultations (0.06%).

When offered a choice of ways to talk to their GP, 27% of patients expressed a preference for a face-to-face appointment, 28% preferred to be contacted by secure message and 44% by phone.  Slightly more patients asked for a face-to-face appointment than in previous months, but clinical decisions and actual method of delivery remain consistent.

The askmyGP data is drawn from practices with diverse patient populations receiving a total of 308,000 patient requests during the period. The data illustrates patient contact by clinical episode, with video consultation with the patient’s usual NHS GP offered at no extra cost to either the practice or the patient.

Clinical judgement always takes precedence, meaning in some cases simple queries might be addressed by a quick answer by phone or message, while more complex presentations will warrant a face-to-face appointment, even in cases where this has not been requested by the patient.  Practices are not bound by their patients’ contact preferences, but they use the information to guide their responses to patients.

13 November 2019

The latest figures from askmyGP reporting patient contact preferences show there has been no change in the low demand among patients for video consultations.

The askmyGP data for the second quarter of 2019 is drawn from practices with diverse patient populations receiving a total of 220,000 patient requests during the period. The data illustrates patient contact by clinical episode, with video consultation with the patient’s usual NHS GP offered at no extra cost to either the practice or the patient.

When offered a choice of ways to talk to their GP, 21% (Q1 25%) of patients expressed a preference for a face-to-face appointment, 29% (Q1 28%) preferred to be contacted by secure message and 49% (Q1 47%) by phone. Patients requested a video consultation in less than 0.1% (Q1 0.1%) of cases.

While practices are not bound by their patients’ contact preferences, they use the information to guide their responses to patients. Clinical judgement always takes precedence, meaning in some cases simple queries might be addressed by a quick answer by phone or message, while more complex presentations will warrant a face-to-face appointment, even in cases where this has not been requested by the patient.

13 August 2019

Many have wondered whether patient satisfaction is affected by their chance of seeing a GP face to face.  The study done for the Exeter Annual Scientific Meeting of SAPC (Society for Academic Primary Care) analysed 14,009 patient feedbacks from 423,143 episodes managed through askmyGP from 1 January to 26 June 2019.

Presented by Ian Barratt and Steve Black at the conference.  Download pdf here.

We’re delighted to inform you today of the open access publication from Abi Eccles et al:

“BJGP: Patient use of an online triage platform”

It’s the first independent study of askmyGP and it’s well worth reading in full.  I will quote the conclusion briefly:

“Patterns-of-use and patient types were in line with typical contacts to GP practices. Though the age of users was broad, highest levels of use were from younger patients. The perceived advantages to using online triage, such as convenience and ease of use, are often context dependent.”

What comes through for me is the very ordinariness of the online demand.  It’s the same as normal demand, same patients, same conditions, same frequency by day of week and time of day.

There’s more on patient feedback too, with themes extracted which are very familiar to us.   We’ve quantified the age question in our study on “Age specific adoption of online consultations.”

What this study adds is online usage orders of magnitude greater than any previous paper, with 5447 patient episodes from 9 practices in 10 weeks.  Data collection was May to July 2017, which was our previous version 2 platform.  Since then the same principles have been carried forward to v3 with a new design and many more features.  Growth in usage means that we are now collecting the same volume of data roughly every two days.

The scope for further research is increasing daily with an anonymised database of some 300,000 episodes, unique in general practice.  If you’re an academic in the field, we welcome the opportunity to collaborate, particularly on studies of the GP practice as a whole, not just online components.

Benefits for patients and GPs are the product of system change.

Regards,

Harry Longman

PS See how patients interact with askmyGP on our Bramley Demo Practice.

To experience the GP side, start with our free online demo.

Context

The latest data from our chief analyst Dr Steve Black (@sib313) shows remarkable adoption of online consultations across all ages and 10 diverse practices.  n = 37,674 requests, date range is 1/1/2019 to 8/2/2019.

The context is all askmyGP practices operating in “total flow” mode where all patient demand goes through the system in two modes.  Online, patients submit a request for help from their NHS GP practice either for themselves (dark blue) or as a proxy (light blue), mostly children but also vulnerable adults, most over 75.  They may also telephone the practice, and a receptionist creates the request on their behalf (orange).

The key point is that all demand is covered in the chart, not from a self-selected subset of patients, and these are regular GP practices where there is no change in registration.

What the data shows

For infants and children, over 60% of parents chose to send their request online.

For young adults aged 20 – 40, over 70% submitted online.

With increasing age, the proportion online falls slowly, but even at 65 – 70 it is 40%.

Over 70 the proportion falls more steeply and significant numbers are by proxy.

Policy implications

It is clear that when designed for ease of use and universality in respect of patients and their medical problems, coupled with rapid response by providers, the online offer is highly attractive to patients.

The vision for “digital-first” providers who are at the same time traditional, local GP practices is achievable and already being achieved.

Harry Longman

Founder, Chief Executive, askmyGP

Good news has a hard time getting heard.

This week we’ve seen new, comprehensive data from NHS Digital on the wait to see a GP, splashed across all the papers:

Guardian:  “One in five patients waits two weeks to see a GP”

Times:  “Millions face a three week wait”

Telegraph:  “One in ten waits three weeks to see their GP”

It’s all “true”, though I’m afraid the spin is not.  The argument that “40% are seen the same day” rings hollow with anyone who has hung on the telephone for half an hour, to be told that all the same day slots have gone.  Many of those 40% have been trying for several days just to get through.

Blame the patients, blame the government, blame whoever else we can think of.  Or take a different look.

These tiny stories from the last few days are just a handful of the hundreds we see each week from patients grateful to their GP:

Your service and reliability are amazing. Thank you! (f 85)

Amazing fast system thank you (m 41)

Amazingly swift and very easy process than trying to jugggle around work – thank you so much! (f 24)

Amazing…More personal…Super speedy  (parent, boy, 3)

Love how easy it is to speak to your own doctor . Amazing (parent, girl, 4)

Love this new system…so easy and quick , and have the problem solved without having to sit around at the surgery. (f 49)

Love ‘askmygp’. Making it so much easier to get info and solve problems whilst holding down a full time job! (f 40)

Wow. I am impressed! (m 69)

Wow, just wow.  Have been in terrible painall night…absolute godsend… Thank you so much for your skills and innovations (f 65)

WOW, great system, quick easy, and no need to travel. Many thanks (m 63)

We’re now over 4,600 feedbacks from 80,000 episodes since August, and the trend is better and better.  Please do have a look at the live rolling 7 day summary chart.   We ask patients whether it’s better or worse and the ratio as I write has moved up to 9 which is so exciting.

These patients are getting an outstanding service from their own regular NHS GPs.  The GPs have no extra funding (they pay us), and no complicated extended hours 8 to 8 hubs (that didn’t work)

Patients didn’t have to switch to an out of area GP.  They could name their own GP.   They were seen same day if needed.

And the GPs are happier too – happier professionally to be giving such a service and bringing the joy back into their working lives.

If you haven’t yet watched the Burnbrae video, please do and click for the demo at the end.  This is one of her 5,000 patients last week, helped within 2 hours: 

“fantastic service and Dr Arnott is an amazing doctor, Shotts is lucky to have all these new changes.”

How do we get this into the headlines?

Regards

Harry Longman